Vegan alternatives to butter
No one has said how tasty these butter swaps are yet. Tried one? Your answer starts the ranking.
How these scores work
People who’ve tried a product rate how close it is to butter in the same flavor, from 1 to 5. Tastiest is a separate ranking of how tasty they found it, whether or not it’s like the original. A brand’s flavors rank together, and each person counts once. Every score starts near the middle of the scale and moves toward what people say as more of them rate it, so a swap with a few high ratings can rank below one that many people rated a little lower. Trending, Newest and Most rated only reorder the list; they never change a ranking, and brands can’t pay to move up.
No butter swaps are ranked yet
Rate one below, or add a product you’ve tried.
Not rated yet
These have no ratings, so they aren’t ranked. Tried one?
Melt Organic Cold Pressed Plant Butteradded Oct 16 · Allergens not confirmed yetBe the first to rate
Melt Organic Cold Pressed Plant Butter Sticksadded Oct 16Be the first to rate
Miyoko's Creamery Cultured & Churned Salted Oat Milk Butteradded Oct 16 · Allergens not confirmed yetBe the first to rate
Miyoko's Creamery European Style Plant Milk Butter Unsaltedadded Oct 16 · Allergens not confirmed yetBe the first to rate
Trader Joe's Organic Buttery Spreadadded Oct 16 · Allergens not confirmed yetBe the first to rate
Earth Balance Organic Whipped Plant Butteradded Oct 16 · Contains soyBe the first to rate
Smart Balance Original Buttery Spreadadded Oct 16 · Allergens not confirmed yetBe the first to rate
Good & Gather Plant Based Organic Non-Dairy Buttery Spread & Sticksadded Oct 16Be the first to rate
Earth Balance Plant Butter Originaladded Oct 23 · Allergens not confirmed yetBe the first to rate
Country Crock Plant Butter with Avocado Oiladded Oct 16 · May contain soyBe the first to rate
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oiladded Oct 16 · May contain soyBe the first to rate
Earth Balance Soy Free Buttery Spreadadded Oct 16 · Allergens not confirmed yetBe the first to rate
Spray Kings Theater Style Butter Flavored Popcorn Sprayadded Oct 16 · Allergens not confirmed yetBe the first to rate
Smart Balance Whipped Buttery Spread with a Hint of Extra Virgin Olive Oiladded Oct 16 · Allergens not confirmed yetBe the first to rate
Allergens come from package labels, and labels and recipes change. Our information may be wrong or out of date. Always check the package.
Know a swap for butter that isn’t here? Add a product. Replacing something else? Suggest a food. Something wrong here? Report this food